Introducing Rembrandt - Hardcover

Grade 3-5-Using an Eyewitness-like, two-page format, Sturgis attempts to introduce Rembrandt's work, explain the triumphs and problems of his personal life, and describe the political realities of his native Holland. Unfortunately, the book misses its mark. While the information itself is generally accurate, the writing is choppy, and facts are not always given in a linear fashion. At times, questions posed are not fully answered. Furthermore, instead of embellishing the text, captions are often the primary source of information, making the narrative difficult to follow. Also, while the author starts out with an admiring tone, he quickly turns to criticizing the artist's motives and even his abilities. There is no glossary; terms such as chiaroscuro, etching, and still life are described but not cross-referenced in the index. Other terms, e.g., print, are never explained at all. While the quality of photos is good, some are too small for discerning detail. In some cases, references are made to a specific photo that does not appear for several pages, and the antique map that shows the artist's birthplace is impossible to read. The final page of text, entitled "Did He Do It?", seems to promote questions rather than add closure to the book. Stick with the "Art for Children" series (Lippincott).
Nancy Menaldi-Scanlan, Wheeler School, Providence, RI
Copyright 1994 Reed Business Information, Inc.